Inside Data Centre Podcast
Who are the people powering the world’s data centers?
Inside Data Centre Podcast is a podcast about the global data center industry, focused on the careers, companies, and conversations shaping modern digital infrastructure. Hosted by Andy Davis, the podcast features interviews with data center professionals, investors, operators, vendors, and industry leaders from around the world. Each episode explores how people enter the data center sector, how their careers develop, and the challenges facing data centers as demand for cloud, AI, and connectivity continues to accelerate. Covering hyperscale, colocation, operations, sustainability, and skills, Inside Data Centre Podcast is essential listening for anyone working in, or looking to work in, the data center industry.
Inside Data Centre Podcast
John Booth, Carbon3IT Ltd: What is sustainability?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode I am joined by John Booth, a specialist data centre consultant at Carbon3IT Ltd. John has an excellent reputation within the sector and market leading knowledge on sustainability and how it impacts the data centre sector.
John explains how he started his career in networking and how this resulted in a career in the data centre sector. John also shares his views on how the sector has changed during his career.
We then discuss sustainability. John gives his views on exactly what sustainability is, why it is important, and how it is going to impact the long term growth of the data centre sector. John also shares his views on renewable energy and how government regulation could impact the long term growth.
John shares some excellent views that will make you think about how the data centre sector will evolve in the coming years.
The Inside Data Centre Podcast is recorded in partnership with DataX Connect, a specialist data centre recruitment company based in the UK. They operate on a global scale to place passionate individuals at the heart of leading data centre companies.
To learn more about Andy Davis and the rest of the DataX team, click here: DataX Connect
Welcome to the Inside Data Centre podcast. I'm Mandy Davis, and in this podcast I will interview the people working in the data centre sector and tell their stories. If you are working in the DC sector or you are looking to work in the sector, then this is a podcast for you. Welcome to the Inside Data Centre podcast. Today I'm joined by John Booth, a specialist consultant within the data centre sector. Good morning, John. Good morning, Andy. Nice to see you on this another sunny day in England. There's two in a row I've done where it's been a sunny English morning. So I need to highlight that point. It's not sunny in the Midlands, unfortunately. Oh, sunny on the South Coast. Um, it's great to have you on. Obviously, really keen to speak to you, dig into your knowledge around sustainability and energy efficiency. I know you've got some you know some great opinions on that. And obviously learn a bit more about yourself, your career, and and how you ended up where you are today in the data centre sector. Before we start, do you just want to give a quick introduction of who you are and what you do? Yeah, so I'm John Booth.
SPEAKER_02I'm the managing director of a company called Carbon Through IT Limited. We're a sustainable IT consultancy and we work primarily in data centre energy efficiency and sustainability. Um, over the last 12 years, I've managed to get myself kind of ingrained in the sector at a quite interesting level. So I'm the chair of the BSI's TCT73 committee, which is the group that developed the EM5600 and ISO 30134 metrics, along with our colleagues in globally. I'm the um chair of the Data Centre Alliance's Energy Efficiency Group, I'm the vice chair of the British Computer Society's Green IT specialist group, I sit on the Infrastructure Mason Sustainability Committee, uh, I'm also on the advisory board of the Sustainable Digital Infrastructure Alliance as well. So, and then there's a few other bits and pieces. I'm an ISO uh lead auditor for energy management, um, and we do training as well for the community.
SPEAKER_01You have no spare time whatsoever.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely not, no. Um it it is, I have to say, um, when we started the company 10 years ago or 12 years ago, we spent the first three probably years quite, you know, not getting much money in, but we were making a lot of connections within the industry. We're going to all the industry events, um, just talking to people, seeing what was going on. So I'm I'm pretty well connected. It takes me, you know, if I if I arrive at a uh show, it normally takes me an hour just to get through the front gate and to get to where I need to get to because I'm saying hello to everybody on the stats. Um, so I think I've got quite a good reputation and um relationship with a lot of people in the industry. I'm known for being independent and honest, you know. I will call a spade a spade and I will call out um rubbish that I see being talked about.
SPEAKER_01Hopefully, we can get some of that on this podcast. But I I always like to go back to the beginning of your career. I think it paints a good picture to the listeners of just how how individuals started. But I notice you are another guest, and a lot of guests are that started as an apprentice, which is great to see. I think it's a great way into any industry. But just interesting know why you chose that career in networks and how you ended up in the data center sector.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's actually um quite interesting because my first love is music production. And um when I was 16, I actually went to the CBS Records um company in Soho Square as a venture scout um to see in the production process of how they they do music. And I was actually offered a messenger job for CBS. Now, you're probably aware that if you, you know, that's your first point into the music business is getting a messenger job. Um, so I I basically came home from school and there were two offers on the on the table. One was from CBS Records and one was from British Telecom to be an apprentice. And um I I I thought long and hard about this, you know, which one should I go for? And eventually um I was persuaded by my parents that the most optional route would be to get an apprenticeship with uh with a with an institution. So I ended up um moving into BT as an apprentice um in the city of London, and and I was there during Big Bang and the expansion of the um of the telecoms network, etc. Um, and then from BT, I I kind of joined a company called Grant and Taylor, which was a structured cabling company, and this was in kind of the early mid-80s, I think. Um, so networking and structured cabling was just coming to the fore. I left Grant and Taylor and worked for a company called Electrical Installations that was part of the Raytheon group. Um I ended up working for Data Logic, did quite a few big uh major cabling infrastructure projects, British Steel at Scomthorpe and Teaside, um, Old War Office, uh, Chelsea and Westminster Hospital projects like that as a junior project manager working with uh more senior guys. Um and you know, and that's a great way of learning on the job, as it were. Um it is a fantastic way of learning, you know, you have to listen to your peers who are older and more experienced than you. And I do remember one particular chap. Um I just started and he said to me, it's what do you know? And I was the arrogance of youth, and I said, Oh, I know everything. And he said, What's the name of my dog? I said, Well, I don't know. And he said, Well, you don't know everything then, do you? And I kind of that that really got to me. And I mean, I'm I'm talking about it, you know, 35 years later. So it you don't know everything, it's impossible to know everything, but you can draw on people that do know, and then that's why I value the network. You know, if I don't know something, I can reach out and talk to people and get the information. And likewise, I have many of my colleagues contact me and say, Oh, I'm doing this. You know, what would you recommend? I mean, I had a I had a conversation yesterday with somebody and just said, um, we're doing a data center upgrade, and um, you mentioned last week on site about maybe having to get implanted permission for a GH uh CHP set. And I said that, well, yeah, you probably will, you know, you can't just turn up and put a gas engine in the in the car park of a data center and not expect the neighbours to complain. So you might want to just check that out. And my advice to him was look, in any data center project, just speak to the planning officer, because the planning officer, informally, the planning officer will be able to tell you exactly what's going on in terms of planning, um, and and and maybe able to point you into the direction of other areas that you need to account for, which is not information you would get um, you know, off the cuff. So it's probably just those that's the sort of thing I do. I'm kind of an information portal, really.
SPEAKER_01Excellent. And I I I love the fact you've highlighted the network as well, because I, you know, I think the data center industry is a great network. I think everyone is really open and happy to help. But the flip of that is you do need to reach out to people and you do need to ask, and they're not going to come to you and and give you that advice. It's about you know using that network wisely and leaning on the people that that you do know. Um, I'm sure you've seen quite a few changes in the sector during your career. Is there anything particular that you can think of that as the where the data center industry has had a sort of a massive shift?
SPEAKER_02I think um as a result of the dot-com boom in the early 2000s, um, there was a lot of speculative building that went on for data centers. Um, to be honest, the the industry per se is only 22 years old, really. Um, the commercial selling of data center space. So I think that was the biggest shift is people going off-premise and into purpose-built facilities. And of course, let's let's there is no bones about this. Data centers are expensive beasts to build and they're expensive to run. Um, and you know, some organizations do need some help. I mean, I have been into some absolute horror stories of data centers, uh I can assure you of that. And um, but that you know, it's a thing that you'd have to carefully consider, you know, lifting and shifting your entire IT estate from a cupboard under the stairs into a data center does have risk, you know. And um, I mean, I remember talking to one guy, and he said, I'll never move my stuff in there to security risk. And I was like, Well, you know, then perhaps you need to think about your security profile and your attack surface um instead of just completely dissing it off. So, yeah, I mean, I so the move to um cloud, I think, or data center services and then to the cloud is the it has been the two biggest things. And I've always said that um, you know, ICT is has two elements in terms of energy efficiency and sustainability. So it's the green in of itself and also the ability to provide greening for everything else, you know. So because we IT has become ubiquitous, it does stretch out through things you wouldn't even think of. Um and and use the use of IT, you know, it's reputed from the, I think it's the JESI report uh 2020 said that you can get six times the benefit of of IT uh in the wider infrastructure. So that's something I'm very keen on is looking from other industries and seeing if we can bring them back into the data center industry.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and lots of people say that actually about looking at other sectors. And I always use Nautilus as an example, you know, Nautilus, Jim Connerton came from the you know the marine sector, and he sort of looked at and thought, well, why are they not doing why why are they not using water? You know, and it's it's simple things like that, but you need that level of intelligence and capability to be able to look at it in a in a way and then implement it into the sector.
SPEAKER_02Well, we actually looked at Nautilus um when even before they built it, they they approached the um the CEDA program to get get the place in it um to do that. But I think it was probably a bit early for them. So hopefully we'll be doing an assessment on uh on the Nautilus uh facility in um is it San Francisco, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yes, yeah.
SPEAKER_02I've never been to San Francisco, so that's like it.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's both go over there then, we'll visit that one. Um obviously brings us nicely on to sustainability, which I know you're you're really passionate about, and obviously energy efficiency as well. And it's something that I talk about every episode. And when I ask people what the major challenges are, you know, sustainability is always in the top two, if it's not number one. Um, so I just wanted to sort of use your knowledge and dig a bit onto that. But to start with, I thought let's ask you know a fairly simple question as far as the question goes, but what is sustainability?
SPEAKER_02Okay, well, the strict definition is um to satisfy the needs of today without compromising the needs of future generations to satisfy their own needs. And I think with ICT that is a real problem because you know, there is only a certain amount of uh rare earths and minerals that are used in in the ICT devices that are available on the planet. Um, you know, once we've extracted them and refined them for our use and then used them, you know, there isn't any more. So we are already compromising future generations in the use of ICT. And I think it's interesting that um people are talking about landfill sites and actually doing mining on original landfill sites because the yield on landfill is actually higher than what you would get in a conventional mine. Um, but obviously that's a finite resource as well. You know, once we've gone in there and done it and processed it, it's going to be difficult to find more. Um so I think that kind of brings into question, you know, the recycling element. You know, we need to be doing more in the recycling instead of sending this stuff to landfill. And I know that over the last five or six years there has been a big drive on recycling. There's the Sedatu project, for instance, there's the um NS2 in in Norwich or somewhere over that way, that's doing um extraction, leech extraction of minerals and stuff. Um, most companies are compelled to do recycling anywhere under the Wii restrictions or the Wii regulations, but there is a lot more stuff to do in the recycling of equipment. And I the other thing is I think we've got to break the vicious circle. You know, it's um it's a fashion item now. You know, I've got my mobile phone here, which is I've just replaced after three years. Um and you think about, but it's still a phone, you know, it's a it's a device that's connected to the net, um, but it's still a phone. Do you really, you know, why there should only be one reason to replace it, and that's if it's broken. You know, we shouldn't have to go through this continual two, three-year cycle. So it's very fashionable to have the latest phone. Um, and I can understand the business model of people like Samsung and Apple, for instance, having to get something out all the time. But then perhaps, you know, in in the area, you know, the era of sustainability and energy efficiency, perhaps they need to reconsider their business models and and maybe change it because you can still make money um from an old device. You just don't need it replacing, you know. Imagine if we were um if we used cars like that and replaced them every two years. And I know we're going down that road with leasing over three-year periods. Um so I think there's a lot of things that need to be done. The business models um for a lot of consumer items need to be re-evaluated. And I think over the next couple of years you will see a kind of change to that. There might even be the leasing of equipment to companies so that at the end of its use it's brought back. And of course, remember, I think what's interesting is you don't get any say in what equipment you're running in a cloud environment, right? All you're offered is a service. So we've got no clue what the big cloud providers are you running on as hardware, um, and also their replacement strategies and refreshment strategies. There was rumors that one of them, the a big search engine, was replacing its kit every nine months. Um, but I don't think that is the case. I think they are extending it. I think they recognize that you know this never-ending replacement cycle, the vicious circle every two years, three years is changing.
SPEAKER_01Do you think one point I just wanted to pick up on that? Do you think it would be driven by the consumer? Do you think it'll be us kind of or the yeah, in general, driving the change? Because the question I always ask, like, is it driven by the customer or is it driven by the the the you know the the client or the operator, whoever it is at the other end? It it's one of those, isn't it? Like it's probably a bit of both, is the answer.
SPEAKER_02But what are your views? In the green IT foundation course that we we um teach, um what we say is is that you know children that are going through the education system are being taught sustainable and energy efficiency, and basically, you know, a whole raft of different things as part of the whole curriculum. So IT and greenness and sustainability and basically looking after the planet, climate emergency, it's all all in every single subject, really. What that does is when they leave, they get the accumulate body of knowledge. And then when they leave school and go into college, they they may be selecting the college or the university they're going to based on the you know the green gowns and the sustainability of that of that particular college. And then once they've gone through further education, they they're selecting the companies they work for on the basis of their ESG credentials. Um, and you know, there is, I think there's a there's a building just opposite Cannon Street. I can't call it who it is, but it's like 70% renewable energy and recyclable, and it's got a completely different makeup to the conventional office environment. Um, and it's all focused on energy efficiency and sustainability. And that was actually driven by the people that work there. You know, if somebody said, right, we're going to go into a new building, how should we do this? Well, let's talk to the people that are going to be using that building. And then so, yeah, I think it it there's there's two ways of looking at it. One, it'll be driven by these kind of um people that are coming out of the education system that are very focused on NSG, the young. And I know that you know, I teach um a data center systems management course to the students at the Birmingham City University, and they are often asking me about, you know, why do we do these things? And I say, well, you know, it's your future, you make the change, you decide to make the change. So I'm very supportive of young people and push them into and to question things, you know. If you don't ask, you won't know. So do that completely. Um, and of course, but the other thing is is that I also think that companies themselves should be a little bit more transparent and and doing stuff because it's good to do. And you know, take we need to take the, and I know this is a very difficult concept to grasp, like, but take that the finance out of it, right? You do something because it's the right thing to do, not because it's going to cost you less or cost you more. Because if you look at some of the ICT infrastructures and the methodologies and data center infrastructure, actually paying a premium at the start for a product reaps reams in the operational expenditure side thing. So the total cost of ownership is very important. Um, and I do think companies should be doing the right thing for the right reasons. Um, and but they should also be broadcasting this fact. You know, we do this because this is what happens at the end, and we do this, you know, we're using this product because it's got a lower cost and it's it's less harmful for the environment, that the extraction is better done, and sort of things like that. So we really haven't answered the question, so it's from both sides, really. But I think both sides have got a part to play. Yes, consumers will be a little bit more picky on who they pick. I mean, we've already seen uh recently um customers are being asked about data center services, and they're being asked specifically about energy efficiency and sustainability, and it's really high on the agenda for customers coming in. You know, what are your ESG credentials?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. And that's what's come up on a lot of these discussions with you know, CEOs or whoever it may be of the larger operators, it is now the customer is asking it, whereas before they were telling them, like, oh, we've got this, this is our ESG. Whereas now the client, the customer's coming to them saying, What is your your ESG credentials?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think the problem is that not all of the um co-location and cloud players are actually um fully transparent. It's a very, I mean, we we're doing a sustainability benchmark and exercise for a client at the moment, and we did one for one last year, where we compared all of the ESG aspects um of various companies, and you know, what were they reporting? What was their overall energy consumption? How many ISOs did they have? Um, have they had any build-in accreditations, etc., for the particular sites? And it's really difficult to actually be able to go, right? Um I want to look at these five companies and whether or not there's any commonality within what they're actually saying. And I think that's that's a question for the industry to be more transparent, but also do it in a standards, a standardized methodology so that you can go in and find out exactly how much energy a particular site's used and compare it to another site and then ask the question why are they using more energy than you? You know, what is it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that makes perfect sense to me from the outside.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think um, you know, I was, as I said earlier, I was on the I was delivering a presentation on sustainability to IT Sligo students last night, and and one of the things um we talk about was the infrastructure mason sustainability framework. And in the in the framework, it there's a very strong focus on transparency. But we need to have some kind of um, for instance, like the ISO 30134 metrics, which is the standardized data center KPIs, which includes PUE, renewable energy factor, energy reuse factor, carbon utilization, water elevation, etc. People are citing them in documents and at events. And then you say, Well, watch them calculate how you're calculating this, and they go, Oh, we use the green red methodology for. I'm sorry, but the greenbird methodology for calculating that was you know 10 years ago and it's now a standard. So you should be calculating it to a standard because otherwise you're just confusing the market. So there's a lot of work to do on there, but it's included in the framework. And it's and and myself and other colleagues that are active in this space have been continually going to events and saying, look, guys, if you're going to report your power utilization effects on this, make sure that you're doing it in as per the way that it's mentioned in the standard, not some, you know, some method that you're using that you've heard about 10 years ago.
SPEAKER_01I did another, I did what an episode on PUE with Mark Acton, just sort of talking about it and we'll quickly touch on it quickly. But you know, like the the misconception, what is PUE for a start? You know, you get this announcement from a data center operator saying we're building this new facility, the PUE is 1.18. No explanation of what 1.18 means. And that's great for people in the sector. But if you want to increase the perception of it, and like you were saying earlier, say what you're trying to do to increase sustainability or improve it, tell them why what that actually means. And I think that's really important.
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, many, many years ago, I remember going to an event. I mean, this is, I think it was data center well, when it was at Olympia, so that's a long time ago. Um, I walked in and there was a stand there. I'm not going to refer to the name of the company because that would be rude. But um, one of the girls went, Oh, would you like to come and hear about our data centers? We've got a PUE of 1.1. And I said, Well, why are you talking to me? You must be full. And she got him, what do you mean? And I said, Well, a PUE of 1.1 to me would indicate that the facility is fairly full because the utilization's gone up. Um, so why are you talking to me? You could you haven't got any space. And she went, Oh, oh, I I maybe I shouldn't have said that. And I said, Yeah, yeah, you probably need to know about PUE before you start searching those things. And I remember going to another event, and I think it was um another data center. Again, I'm not going to mention them because of the embarrassment factor. But then actually said, Oh, we've got a PUE of 0.98. Um, hold on a minute, you can't go below one. Oh, yeah, but we've got solar panels on the roof. No, that doesn't really count. Oh, okay. But they did, I think they that was a calculated decision. They did that because they wanted to be controversial and and and get people to say, but you can't do that. Oh, well, yes, we can, but then show you how we explain how we do things, and we've got this solar panel. Yeah, okay, right.
SPEAKER_01But that that brings us on quite nicely, actually, to renewable energy, which is another topic I know you're you're passionate about. And I again I did a podcast with with Chad Harris in a riot blockchain out in the States in Texas, building a Bitcoin mining facility. And I talked to him about renewable energy, and he said, Oh, you know, Texas are always saying you need to use renewable energy, but there isn't really any renewable energy to use. So it's sort of a bit of a misconception about you can only use what's available. So, what's your views on the the words or the phrase renewable energy?
SPEAKER_02Well, it drives me potty, to be honest. Um, my view, so we have seen a drive over the last probably two years uh of companies saying, Oh, we're using 100% renewable energy, right? And and you go, okay, fine. So you just know from the from who they are and where they're located that that's all virtual power purchase agreements, and they're basically paying a premium for green energy. Um, and I and I think what what annoys me the most is that they're the the kind of promoting this is something good, right? And it is something good, but um, I always resort back to my mantra, which is an inefficient data center powered by renewable energy, is still an inefficient data center. And I remember many years ago um speaking to some guys from Iceland and talking to them about energy efficiency, and they looked at me as if they said, but but we are completely 100% renewable in Iceland. We have geothermal, we have hydro. And and and like energy was too cheap and too plentiful for them to be worried about energy efficiency. And I said, you know, just because you're using renewable energy doesn't mean that you abdicate all of your responsibility for the other kind of energy efficient measures that you can take place. Just because you've got renewable energy doesn't mean you should waste it. And I felt that some countries are wasting uh because they're not doing anything else, and some and some companies are as well. Now, and I'll go back to what I said, you know, an inefficient data center powered by renewable energy is still an inefficient data center. And if you look at any energy efficiency program, what what they say to do is you know, you turn off all of your um stuff you don't need, optimise what's left, and then and only again go to power it all by renewable energy. And I think a lot of the companies have jumped straight from the status quo into oh, we're all powered by renewable energy, without looking at what they can do. And I've seen this, you know, I've been to data center science where they they're still using a caged environment and no hot and cold aisle alignment at all. So you've got heat coming out of the servers going into the input. I mean, it's the right bad old days. This is like, you know, 20 years ago we were doing this, and you know, there are still companies that do this. So anybody with a caged environment, please, please, please, please go into hot and cold aisle alignment and better still contain the environments, and you will save yourself a shed load of money. Now I know this because I went to a data center in Mexico in a caged environment with all the servers, none aligned. And I said to them, look, please look at the code of conduct, and we'll probably talk about that in a moment. Uh, go to const go to hot oil and then think about containment. And I didn't think they were going to do it, you know, and they came back to us within four months and said, right, we've persuaded all of our customers to go to hot cold aisle alignment um by offering them free hosting for a month. We did all the work, and we've saved 40,000 euros in air conditioning a month, right? That's 1.2 million euros a year just by going from a caged environment to hot cold environment. And then if you contain it over the top, I'm sure there'd be another amount of money to be saved. And you know, you still get the same security. You can put a key print, thumbprint, or key fob access control on the front of your cabinet, you can put it on the on the door of the cabinet. So you, you know, this security aspect that some and it is, you know, this is security from the 90s. Um, there's all sorts of the security element has increased somewhat. And to be fair, you know, when was the last time you heard of a data center actually being broken into uh and data stolen from inside the facility? Very, very rare. But most of the time you'll you'll hear about it, it's oh, it was hacked via the internet, which is the preferred method. You know, who wants, you know, if you are a hacker or you want to find information out, the last thing you're gonna do is break into a facility. So I think we some of the one of the other things is that you know, risk and security of data centers, I think is probably has been taken as far as it can go. And we really, really the industry really needs to reconsider the perception of risk and how it applies it, um, because that will reduce cost. And if we start reducing cost, and then we can maybe, and I uh I'm sure the security companies are screaming at me now, we like cages, but you know, again, um we're in a different world. We, you know, sustainability and energy efficiency are going to be important moving forward, and companies are gonna have to adapt or die, to be honest. And um, if you're so here's a note if you're making cages, you might want to think about doing this uh moving into a different market.
SPEAKER_01Free advice for you. And there is actually a famous uh London data center heist, isn't there? From uh I always forget what, like from about the is it the 80s or 90s where they actually broke into a data center and stole the the chips.
SPEAKER_02They did, that was Deutsche Bank, actually. Um, and that was during the great chip shortage, memory shortage. Um, but that was I I hesitate to say this real. I think um it was so slick.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's what it's a there's an actual um I saw it on TV, I think, or or read a book about it. It's it's worth looking up anyway, listed. Have a look. It's a it's a it's a good story in a bad way.
SPEAKER_02It was it was well slicked because they basically got in. Um they actually, I think they did hurt the security guard, but they knew exactly where they were going, right? And they knew exactly what servers to go for, and they were in and out in a very short period of time. Um, and the first anybody knew about it was, I think, in the knock operations when all of a sudden all of these servers started going on.
SPEAKER_01And I think it it was a classic getaway on a boat up the Thames as well, I think, if I if I remember rightly, it was very well structured. Surprise me. But anyway, um, brings us on quickly just before we sort of obviously running out of time, but from uh regulation in the sector, um you know, it's something again a lot of people are asking will we see more government regulation? You know, where do we sit right now? But from an energy efficiency and sustainability perspective, you know, what's available and how do you see it changing in the next sort of few years?
SPEAKER_02Okay, do you want me to talk about the EU side of things or just in the UK? Because I think we'll well, I'll talk about the EU, right? So I think one of the biggest problems is is that um we don't actually have a steer on how much energy is being used by um data centers and server rooms per se. We have some estimates, and you know, these estimates are all very well-meaning, and then they give you their calculation. But every time I look at one, I go, well, you know, you've completely missed the distributed IT that is in um that are server rooms in organizations, under stairs, little cupboards, you know, four or five rack facilities with two air conditioning units that are probably the most energy inefficient. So we we we don't know, all we have is is some of the big, you know. I think the latest thing was it's like 1.1% of global energy is used for data centers. The thing is, though, is to look through the the smoke and the mirrors that is applied to that, because that only applies to hyperscale and co-location data centers. Um, and they are, you know, the the it's the but they're the top of the iceberg, right? And it's what's underneath the iceberg that we really need to be worried about. So we did some assessment back in the after the climate change agreement in the UK um back in 2017, and the data that came back said that there was, I think it was 2.579 terawatt hours used um in the UK in in that previous reporting period. And it had something like 130 odd data centers in there. Um, so I kind of did a very basic um research and I looked at the Bayes and the um government websites and find out how many uh found out how many organizations there were that had over 250 employees based on the fact that they were more likely to have a on-site server room and maybe not be in the cloud. And that we found out that there were 33,000 businesses that had um over 250 employees, and then there was a further 7,000 that had over kind of a thousand employees. So we kind of extrapolated it up, and um we worked out that there was probably uh 80,000 small server rooms um in the UK, and that spread amongst government, academia, police, um, five commercial enterprises, etc. And that each um, and we did extrapolate this. We said that there would probably be about 50 IT items within a server room, um, including servers, network, storage, and that overall they would cost around 57,000 a year to run. And if you multiplied that by the 80,000, then you get between um four and six billion pounds used in energy consumption for ICT equipment, depending on the tariff, because obviously some organizations would have a quite good tariff and others would have a you know a straightforward commercial tariff. And that actually equated to 41 terawatt hours, which was 12 percent of the UK um energy grid. And you know, I I when I finished that research, I went, I think it was actually in November, so I went to a few of the big shows and I spoke to various people at quite high level that that talk about this. And I mentioned this study, and none of them, none of them pushed back and said, That's that's rubbish job, right? You know, they all said, Yeah, big problem, one that's hidden. Um, I think what's happened in the EU is that they are recognizing that it is causing problems in energy consumption, but also the location of where that energy is being used. And they have in their recent 55 proposals put um kind of mandatory data center registry for each member state to create. Um that's a good thing until you look and to see where the threshold is. Okay, and actually the proposal to lower the threshold was actually put forward by a co-location operator that said, you know, if we're gonna do if we're gonna have a mandatory registry, which we're quite happy to have, but we need to find out exactly and we need to cover all data center type operations, remote, edge, etc., and also commercial on-premise, small data centers, 50 hundred kilowatts. So if that proposal gets approved by the European Parliament, then it will be enacted in the revision of the Energy Efficiency Directive. And then we'll get a really accurate steer on exactly how much energy there is. The drawback being obviously then also governments will know about this, and they will then potentially have some um regulations that they wish to apply. Now, in the UK, it's a bit lazer fair to be honest. So the only thing we've got is the climate change agreement, which only applies to commercial data centres. The rest of the energy consumption is is kind of captured in the ESOS regulations, the energy saving opportunity scheme regulations, and potentially the SECA regulations, which is the streamlined energy and carbon reporting regulations. But I the the the former, the ESOS regulations, is merely the identification of an opportunity. You are not compelled to actually act upon the opportunities that you've identified. And I suspect that the next, and of course, that that was that legislation arose out of the energy efficiency directive from the EU, Article 7 and 8. And I know that the Article 7 and 8 does plan for the next phase to be right. So you've had three phases where you've identified opportunities. The fourth phase is you know, get your finger out, start spending some money, and act upon those identified, you know, the opportunities you've identified. I think you know, the UK government has been focused on on one thing um over the last six or seven years, and and maybe energy has kind of um fallen to the point. But what has come in stark kind of uh realization is is that hold on, guys, you know, energy is spiking now, big time. I I think sooner rather than later there will be some sort of regulation in the UK on data centres. Um and it it would be down to me and some of my colleagues that operate at this level to kind of shape government policy on this because we don't want a kind of blanket, you know, bosh, this is what's gonna happen. It needs to be the problems of energy efficiency in data incentives need to be uh understood by regulators before they start legislating on them. Um, because that can lead to you know uh perverse incentives. Um and using PUE, for instance, as a as a measure of efficiency, you know, is fraught with danger because you know most people, you could even, you know, if you wanted to, you could go, right? I'm gonna I'm gonna put lighting, task lighting into USB sockets on servers, um, and I'm gonna put my data into darkness. And I and then I would look at somebody who who said that to me and go, you're mad, because lighting accounts for something like 0.5% of a data center's energy consumption. Um, I'd be more impressed if you started using free cooling or um had an active um you know linking server use with rear door cooling, um, you know, and some of the newer concepts and technologies. Whatever happens, I know that the professional sector will be kicking back on any proposal that comes out of government um because that's what you know that's what they're paid to do. Um but I think that they're slowly but surely I think they're recognising that you know we are in a different era and energy efficient and um sustainability is very important, and that you know it'll be a question of if you don't do this, we're just gonna legislate you. Um and it in some cases it might be you know to the point of the company goes bust.
SPEAKER_01Um I've been saying all year as well. It's it's like before we finish up, but it's it's good news that people are talking about the industry, it's you know, but that also creates problems, doesn't it, or challenges. It it creates you know eyes from outside onto the sector. Whereas when we were under the radar, which we very much were for you know only a few years back, people didn't really know what was happening, whereas now they do, and that will drive the regulation.
SPEAKER_02I think, yeah, the the biggest, I do think some sections of the industry did shoot itself in the foot with the climate neutral data center pact, um, you know, because they went um, they basically said, Oh, look, we don't really want to be regulated by you, but we'll have a self-regulatory pact. So what we'll do is we'll we'll we'll cover the the main things and then we'll and we'll report on those. Um and then um, you know, and and then hopefully you won't legislate. And the commission went, oh well, fantastic, thank you very much. Um so you're gonna get all these companies to report the data to you, are you? Okay, yeah. No, no, you're gonna report it to us, um, which is why they've got the the um that that proposal for the mandatory data center energy, which actually does include, you know, you've got to provide your energy consumption, where it's sourced from, um, what level it is, um, your water usage, uh, and other things that are in there. So um if if you were looking at it from a pack perspective, have you been successful? Or were you been successful in and gathering all these trade organizations across Europe and some of these big players into it um to fight the government? Um but unfortunately that battle has been lost because the the government have just said, yeah, well, if you're gonna report this data, give it to us and then we'll take it. So um, yeah, and I think so that the discussions between the Climate Neutral Data Center Pact and the European Commission are ongoing, but we've got to remember that some of the players that are in the pact are also based in Europe in the UK. And whatever happens in Europe, you know, they're not gonna have two different systems, right? You know, why would they? They're not gonna have a UK-only system, they'll they'll just use the EU regulations and apply them to their own say, and then you know, the UK government to go, yeah, you know, let's accept that data because we know it its provenance and how it's been calculated, etc. So, and that's if you know they do that. I think the problem we've got in the UK is that in the commission, there is a separate data center and cloud group contained within DG Connect. So the digital, the Directorate General for Connection, which is digital infrastructure and and all things digital, there is a separate cloud and data center unit in it. In the UK, to be honest, I don't know where the data center unit is, right? And I'm working in this sector. Um, I have a suspicion it's buried deep in the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, which again would be well, why is it in there? Um and I think that's a fundamental misunderstanding of how actual, how important the digital sector is to the UK. You know, it should have its own separate department, in my opinion, for all things digital. And then there should be a separate department within government, within. That department that's concentrated solely on data centers in terms of regulation and information gathering, which again can be cascaded out. But you know, at the moment, I'm we're talking to Bayes, we've been talking to the Department of Culture, Media and Sport, we've been talking to other people, um, with it, you know, the infrastructure projects authority, for instance. So there's at least three different bodies in the UK government that has, if not direct, um, responsibility for they are definitely got their spoon in the pot and they're stirring it. Um, and I think you know, from from just from an industry perspective, just have one regulator and one person to talk to rather than spreading across three, you know. Definitely, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And hopefully the right person's listening to this uh to this episode and they uh and they can do that for us. But obviously, you've shared some great insight into sustainability. I think you've offered some excellent advice as well to people. But there's one question I ask everyone, just as a final question. And I know you work with you know a lot of young people, so I'm quite interested to hear your views. But if there's one piece of advice you could give to anyone looking to work in the sector, what would it be?
SPEAKER_02Okay, so if you're in the south of England, um at what age range are we talking about? School any age. Okay, well, so so obviously um anybody that lives in the Slare area um that wants to get into the data center career, there's the then new UTC and just opened up at Slough run by CNET and and the um Slough guys. So that that would great entry point into for to get a career in in the Slare area. But you know, data centers are global. So if you're um if you're kind of going into college and you're in the Birmingham area, then perhaps come on my uh Birmingham City University uh data center systems management module, which is kind of like uh a data center 101 over 12 weeks, and we go into some serious detail on uh everything data center related. Um yeah, it's an interesting, it's a great opportunity. And if in terms of education, you could you could do a conventional apprenticeship and go this the route that most people have done, which is either a mechanical or electrical apprenticeship or even an IT um apprenticeship, and then you know you'll be warmly welcomed into the data center area. But not to forget that you know a data center is a business like any other, so it has marketing, it has sales, it has management. Um, so you can still be involved in industry um you know and not get your hands dirty and don't have to wear overalls and corporate you know protection, um, you can still do that. And of course, there's there's all of a supply chain you can work in. I mean, at the moment, you know, uh I think from recent reports I've read, 300,000 jobs in the data center industry before 2025 or 2030 uh globally. Um and if you get yourself a job safe with somebody like Equinix or Global Switch or Interaction, um you can move within companies. So if you fancied a little trip to Australia and working in an Aussie data center, then I'm sure that there'll be vacancies that you could apply for internally. Um and you know, people might want to go to China or Japan or some places where they would never experience going. The industry is it's spreading, you know. Um the amount of new builds, and I and Andy, you're great at pushing out your your newsletter, weekly newsletter of where the new builds are happening, you know, from from my point of view, I I look I read them sometimes and I think there's more more energy, more, more resources being consumed. Um but on the on the flip side of that, you know, we are spreading the only 50% of the world are online, right? So that we for whatever infrastructure we've got now, we're gonna have to duplicate it just to get the rest of the world online. So yeah, go on a training course. There's there the the opportunities for working in the data center industry are huge globally. Um, and you'll be more than welcome to come in. You know, it's it's a it's a great job. You know, I've been doing it for since some years, yeah. I think um, in fact, uh 41 years I've been working. So, you know, in 1981 I started uh as a BT apprentice, and now we're here in 2022. I've got my own business, um, hopefully respected around the world. Um, speak on a regular basis. I've had the you know, the in the last 12 years, I've had the best fun I've ever had. You know, I've I've been to Australia, I've been to South America, I've been to America, I've been to Europe, uh, Asia Pac, India, loads of times. I've met people in the industry. Um, we've all we've all got the same problems, right? The only difference, you know, and I often said, you know, if you're inside a data sector, when I worked for the foreign office, um doing installed stuff, sometimes you'd be in in a room working on a computer, and you get so wrapped up in it, you didn't know you couldn't, you forgot where you were, right? Because they're exactly the same, and you'd walk out and you'd only know where you were on the temperature and humidity. So you'd come out in the middle. I mean, I did um I did uh one in India, one in Cambodia, and um one in Belarus, and um yeah, the two the two kind of Indian and Cambodian ones come out very hot, you know, even at eight o'clock in the evening it was hot and humid. Uh Belarus was breezing. Um so yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, and I think I think that's a great way to finish it though, because I think fun is a brilliant way to describe this sector, and and no one's really said that before, and you know, everyone shares similar, but it is a really fun industry, and everyone in it is is a is a it's a great bunch of people.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, you know, we've only got to go to some of the trade events and uh kind of swagger in right to uh a little bit. You can have some fun, you can have a lot of fun. Um, and I have had a lot of fun. I think what was it? Um Billy Mack said in um love actually, right at the end. We've had a lot of fun. Yeah, we have had a lot of I've had a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And what a great way to end it. I really appreciate your time, John. You've shared an excellent insight into you know your career, but also sustainability, energy efficiency, renewable energy, buzzwords that we all talk about, but maybe we don't really know what they mean, and hopefully now a few people do. So I really appreciate you taking the time to speak with me today.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. It's been a pleasure, actually. Um yeah, oh yeah, it's been a busy week and it's gonna get busier.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And we'll do it again sometime.
SPEAKER_02We will. Okay, great. Thanks, John. Take care. Yeah, and you, thanks, Andy.